|
Post by ignorantianescia on Oct 24, 2012 7:23:31 GMT
Michael Ruse has had another shot arguing (imo not very convincingly) that Humanism is at least similar to a religion. What I find more interesting is how he relates Thomas Huxley's, Julian Huxley's, Edward Wilson's and Richard Dawkins's views. www.aeonmagazine.com/world-views/michael-ruse-humanism-religion/With the Dawkins-Williams confrontation, history was repeating itself. In 1860, a year after the publication of On the Origin of Species, the British Association for the Advancement of Science met at the Oxford University Museum. Darwin himself had long ceased to go to this kind of gathering, which was designed to explain and celebrate the achievements of science both to scientists and to the general public. He was always sick and had, moreover, grown to dislike the physical aspects of controversy — getting up and confronting opponents in person. No such qualms were felt by his most devoted and closest followers, the botanist Joseph Hooker and the anatomist and paleontologist Thomas Henry Huxley. They knew that Darwin’s theory of evolution through natural selection was going to be the topic of the day and that the critics were spoiling for a fight. In a way, it was a holy mission — the two knights out there to promote and protect the reputation of their sick leader. If only Wagner had been an Englishman: instead of Parsifal, we might have had Darwin.
|
|
|
Post by unkleE on Oct 24, 2012 12:22:49 GMT
I think Ruse is claiming parallels between humanism and religion only in their similar (he says) psychological and sociological effects - as he says:
"The Humanism I have been discussing in this piece does bear strong similarities to conventional religion. One finds the enthusiasm of the true believer, and this encourages a set of unnerving attributes: intolerance, hero-worship, moral certainty and the self-righteous condemnation of unbelievers. As an atheist Darwinian evolutionist, as one who is a humanist in the broader sense, this makes me feel really ill."
|
|